Is Renting Really a Waste?

The decision to buy a house is not an easy one. While there are certainly times when purchasing a home makes good practical and financial sense, the truth is that it is not for everyone. However, many are led to believe that the alternative — renting — is a waste of money. Is this true?

As often touted as the saying that renting is just throwing money away is, it’s also misleading. Although many assume that $1,000 in rent is equivalent to $1,000 mortgage payment, there are many other factors that make that false. In fact there are many things you should consider before ditching the rental life.

The first step is to take a closer look at what owning a home costs. Beyond the mortgage itself, there are homeowners association (HOA) fees, property taxes, and insurances that you’ll also be responsible for. Additionally while many rentals include all necessary maintenance, owning a home means you’ll need to pay for repairs and upgrades to items like appliances that can cost a pretty penny.

One reason people assume they should purchase a house is because of the equity they can acquire as the home value rises. Unfortunately that’s a two-way street and you could run the risk of owing more on your home than it is worth — often referred to as being “upside-down” or “underwater.” If you plan on staying in your home for the entire length of your mortgage or beyond, this might not be such a problem. However, if you plan on moving this could cause a true hardship that those who rent would not experience.

Along those lines one major thing to consider before jumping into a home purchase is how long you plan to live there. In theory you could always sell your home whenever you’d like and move elsewhere, but that’s usually easier said than done. In fact depending on the market, selling your house could be a lengthy process. Because of this, if you’re in a job that has the potential for relocation you may want to give renting a second thought.

Another consideration to make before buying is how flexible your finances are. Owning a home means that your finances will not be as predictable as they are when renting (especially if you opt for a adjustable rate mortgage instead of a fixed rate). Once again it’s important to remember that being able to afford a mortgage and being able to afford a home are not the same thing.

A powerful resource for helping you decide whether buying is for you is this New York Times rent or buy calculator. This site takes into account some of the factors we’ve discussed to give you a (closer to) apples to apples comparison about which may be right for you based on finances. That being said, there are of course personal factors such as location, taste, and lifestyle that may also influence your decision but cannot be easily quantified.

When it comes down to it renting is not just a waste of money. There are many legitimate reasons why renting may make more financial sense than buying despite what some might say. Buying a home is not something you should feel guilted or pressured into, so make sure you consider everything that comes along with owning a house before calling the realtor.

Author

Jonathan Dyer

I'm a small town guy living in Los Angeles looking to make solid financial decisions. I write for a number of finance websites, including HuffingtonPost and Business2Community. I founded DyerNews.com in 2015 to focus on personal finance and the emerging FinTech markets.

Other Articles by Jonathan Dyer

Marqeta Expands Credit Program with New APIs and More

A FinTech that specializes in creating credit card experiences is rolling out some new features. This week, Marqeta announced what it calls a "significant expansion" of its credit platform. This includes more than 40 new credit APIs that will further help clients craft and launch their own credit card products. Additionally, the company notes an updated intuitive dashboard. Using this platform, businesses can create unique card options that can not...

PayPal Launches Small Business Credit Card with Flat 2% Cashback

The popular platform PayPal is rolling out a new product built specifically for small businesses. Today, the FinTech announced the launch of The PayPal Business Cashback Mastercard. The new card will be issued by WebBank and marks the first time PayPal has offered a business credit card. With the PayPal Business Cashback card, business owners will be able to earn 2% cashback on all purchases. This earning rate is not...

Wells Fargo Unveils New Autograph Rewards Visa Card

A new rewards credit card is on the way from Wells Fargo. Today, the bank introduced its Autograph card, which expands the company's refreshed card portfolio. In terms of rewards, the Wells Fargo Autograph Card will earn 3 points per dollar spent in a number of categories. These include restaurants, travel and transit, gas stations, select streaming services, and phone plans. All other purchases will earn 1x points. Beyond the...