2019 Credit Sesame Review: What It Tells You About Your Credit

Home » Product Reviews » Financial » 2019 Credit Sesame Review: What It Tells You About Your Credit

2019 Credit Sesame Review: What It Tells You About Your Credit

Do you know what your credit looks like? If not, there are now several completely free services that will not only give you a peek at your credit score but can also give you guidance into how you can improve it. One such offering is Credit Sesame.

A while back I signed up for Credit Sesame, not so much to learn about my own credit, but to see how their product matched up to other options like Credit Karma. Before I dive into that part of my review, let me first explain how Credit Sesame works, starting with how to sign up.

How Credit Sesame Works

As advertised, Credit Sesame is completely free to sign up for. Thus you won’t have to enter a credit card number or worry about canceling some subscription you don’t want in order to get your score. However, you will need to enter your typical info such as name, address, etc. as well the last four digits of your social security number.

After entering your information you are then required to take a quiz of sorts, answering questions related to your credit history in order to prove your identity. Once you pass that test, it’s off the races.

One more thing to note is that, if you currently have a security freeze on your credit reports, you’ll likely need to temporarily “thaw” them in order to complete the Credit Sesame sign-up process. However, once you’re set up, you can refreeze your reports without issue. Additionally using Credit Sesame will not affect your credit scores.

Navigating Credit Sesame — “My Finances”

Your dashboard, once logged into Credit Sesame, is pretty straightforward although there are some quirks. When you first log in, you’ll see a score displayed along with an adjective to let you know where you stand (e.g. “excellent” or “poor”). This particular score is from TransUnion, one of the three major credit bureaus. Something else to note is that, like with other free credit sites, Credit Sesame uses the VantageScore 3.0 model to provide scores as opposed to the FICO models utilized by most creditors. As a result, these “educational scores” may differ from what creditors will see — although the discrepancies shouldn’t be too drastic in most cases.

From your dashboard, you’ll see a series of tabs, with “My Finances,” being the primary one. “My Finances” also contains five subsections, the first of which is “My Credit.” When the “My Credit” tab is clicked, you’ll be able to dive into the various credit factors and how you rate in each. For example my payment history, credit usage, credit age, and credit inquiries were all graded ‘A.’ However my account mix was a ‘D’ since I currently only have revolving credit and no installment loans.

Clicking each of the aforementioned tabs will also give you greater insight into why the site graded you the way it did. This not only includes helpful information such as what your actual credit utilization is but also provides tips and best practices to help improve your score if you’re not ‘A’ rated. For example, when it comes to credit utilization, it shows that it rated me at a ‘B’ because I was currently using between 11% and 30% of my total credit limit. It then suggests that my goals should be to bring that figure under 10% in order to bump up to an ‘A.’

Other interesting tidbits include a look at the average age of your credit, which is something you’re unlikely to know offhand. While your rating is based on the average length of your credit, the site breaks out what your oldest and youngest accounts are as well. Once again they also offers insight into your rating, noting that, “By keeping your average account age over 5 years, you are showing creditors and lenders what they like to see.”

Next up is the “My Debt” tab. Here you can see all of your outstanding debts and calculate your debt to income ratio. As a result, this section could likely be useful for someone working their way out of debt and wants to monitor their progress. Similarly those monitoring their credit utilization and spending might also find this section helpful.

The other two main tabs — “My Monitoring” and “My Credit Report” — are mostly reserved for Credit Sesame’s premium products. The bulk of the “My Monitoring” page is an ad asking you to “Unlock My Identity Protection Alerts,” with plans ranging from $9.95 to $19.95.

However, if you click the “free credit monitoring and identification protection” with the bell icon in the upper right of the page, you can adjust your settings for the free monitoring that comes with your Credit Sesame account as well as other alerts (more on that later). Additionally, if you look to the left, you’ll see a section titled “Credit Monitoring” that will give you access to alerts such as new accounts opened or inquiries made.

Similar to the ad on the monitoring page, the “My Credit Report” tab allows you to either sign up for a subscription or buy a one-time copy of your report for $9.95. So, unless you have a premium subscription or want to purchase a copy of your report, this tab won’t be of much service.

The fifth and final tab is “My Financial Goals.” Here you’ll be able to select from a number of goals including raising your credit score, buying a home, refinancing a loan, and more. Once you update the data for your selected goal, you can browse through advice and/or offers to help you achieve it.

Credit Sesame Recommendation and Credit Card Tabs
Despite there “My Finances” section housing the bulk of what Credit Sesame has to offer, there are still some other prominent tabs to discuss. Unfortunately most of them offer largely the same thing: credit card ads.

Directly next to “My Finances” is “My Recommendations,” which will suggest various credit cards the site thinks might be a good fit for you. Along with your approval odds for these cards, it also gives an overview of what you need to know about each, such as annual fees, initial bonuses, and other perks. Recommendations are also broken down into sections, including cards suited for balance transfers, ones that earn you airline miles, and those that offer cash back.

Next up is “Borrowing Power,” which also features credit card promotions. This time, however, they are arranged by the credit limit the site believes you could qualify for. On top of the credit cards, this page does include other credit products like personal loans and mortgages as well.

Following the “ID Protection,” tab (which is identical to the “My Monitoring” section we discussed earlier) is yet another section dedicated to credit cards — this time simply titled… well… “Credit Cards.” There are actually subsections here, offering a look at overall “Best Cards” or recommendations for students, cash back cards, balance transfers and more. Admittedly the “Pros” and “Cons” sections here can be helpful if you’re not exactly sure what you’re looking for.

Alternatively the “Search All Cards” option in the drop-down menu will bring you to a marketplace where you can toggle various options to drill down your card options. These options include Approval Odds, Features, Reward Types, Category (Personal, Business, Student), Network (Visa, Mastercard, Discover), and Issuer. Honestly, I think this is the most helpful card recommendation tool Credit Sesame offers and it makes me wish it was more prominently featured.

Comparing Credit Sesame and Credit Karma

Having reviewed Credit Karma in one of my first Money at 30 columns, I couldn’t help but compare the two products while reviewing Credit Sesame. Unfortunately for the latter, that comparison isn’t very favorable. For starters Credit Karma’s interface feels much cleaner and more intuitive than Credit Sesame’s. Additionally, since Credit Karma doesn’t offer any premium, paid services, you don’t encounter upsell pages like you do with Credit Sesame.

One thing Credit Sesame does offer that Credit Karma doesn’t is identity theft insurance. In fact, Credit Sesame offers users $50,000 in protection just for signing up. Additionally I found their e-mail and SMS alert settings to be helpful, including the ability to get notified if your score goes above or below a certain threshold. While Credit Karma does offer many other options for customized alerts, this particular setting is not one of them (at least not that I could find). In my opinion, this is actually a pretty glaring omission on Credit Karma’s part so I’m glad Credit Sesame picks up the slack.

However the biggest difference between the two platforms is how much information you can get for free. First, Credit Karma offers free users two scores (TransUnion and Equifax) while Credit Sesame’s free service only offers one (TransUnion). For the record, my score displayed on both sites did match each other, so that’s a good sign.

Another difference is that Credit Sesame only allows you to buy a copy of your credit report or subscribe to their service. Meanwhile Credit Karma offers much of this info for free and even arranges it in an easy-to-explore format. Having not purchased a report from Credit Sesame I can’t say for sure how it compared but, for free, Credit Karma’s reports are definitely useful.

Lastly it should be noted that both services make money by suggesting credit cards and loans that might appeal to users. Still I couldn’t help but feel like that fact was much more obvious on Credit Sesame than on Credit Karma. That could also be due to the navigation design but there seemed to be an ad at every turn. Because of this I find myself using Credit Sesame less frequently than Credit Karma.

Premium services

As I mentioned, while Credit Sesame offers a completely free plan that includes your TransUnion credit score, $50,000 in identity theft insurance, and more, they also offer premium services as well. These plans come in three tiers: Advanced Credit, Pro Credit, and Platinum Credit, which cost $9.95 a month, $15.95 a month, and $19.95 a month respectively. While the features differ as you work your way up the ladder, the main selling points include access to monthly credit scores from all three main bureaus along with full credit reports (of note: these scores are still derived from the VantageScore 3.0 model, not FICO). Some of the other premium features included with higher-grade subscriptions include 24/7 assistance with credit reporting errors, public records monitoring, social security number monitoring, $1 million in identity theft insurance, and more.

Personally, I haven’t tried any of Credit Sesame’s premium services so I can’t really speak to whether or not they’re worth it. That said, those interested in getting a fuller picture of their credit situation — including having access to Experian scores that not even Credit Karma offers — might consider taking these services for a test spin.

Final Thoughts on Credit Sesame

Overall Credit Sesame is worthy as a free service. Even though I prefer Credit Karma on the whole, I see no reason not to use both since there are a few unique features offered by each app. In fact, I actually do utilize both services on a regular basis as Credit Sesame offers some alert options that Credit Karma does not. So, if you’re looking for insight into your credit score and how to improve it, Credit Sesame is a great place to start.


Kyle Burbank

Kyle is a freelance writer and author whose first book, "The E-Ticket Life" is now available on Amazon. In addition to his weekly "Money at 30" column on Dyer News, he is also the editorial director and a writer for the Disney fan site LaughingPlace.com and has recently starting publsihing his own personal finance blog at https://moneyat30.com/

Other Articles by Kyle Burbank

Money at 30: EveryDollar Review

For the most part, a lot of the budgeting apps I've reviewed have been fairly similar. Although they might include some different features and interfaces, they all largely do the same thing. That's what makes EveryDollar stand out as a unique option — for better or worse. So what is...

Encircle Review — An Easy Way to Inventory Your Belongings

Take a second to think about all of the things that you own. If you're like most people, chances are that you'd be hard-pressed to make a comprehensive list of these items — let alone price them out if need be. While it may not be top of mind, there...

Money at 30: "Passive Income, Aggressive Retirement" Book Review 3

As I may have mentioned in earlier columns, I've been making a point of doing more book reviews as of late. Yet, when I set out this goal, I didn't really have a reading list in mind. That's why it's always exciting to discover a new potential option — in...


Been using Credit Karma for a while now and so far happy with it, but i find your review interesting and maybe i will give credit sesame a try.

Credit sesame is easy to use and i like how information is being categorized and presented, but honestly I can’t compare it with other sites because I’ve been using credit sesame ever since.

Comments are closed.