Renters Insurance: How Pennies a Day Can Save You Thousands

Home » Money Management » Personal Finance » Renters Insurance: How Pennies a Day Can Save You Thousands

Renters Insurance: How Pennies a Day Can Save You Thousands

Do you have renters insurance? Have you ever even heard of it? If not, you’re certainly not alone as surveys have found that less than 40% of those who rent carry a renters insurance policy. When you consider the fact that 95% of home owners have homeowners insurance, it’s clear to see that renters insurance has a real awareness problem.

Despite its apparent lack of popularity, I’ve had quite a few random run-ins with renters insurance over the years. As I’ve mentioned before, the first of these encounters came while watching an episode of Friends. In this particular episode, Rachel’s father is appalled to learn that the Manhattanite doesn’t have a renters insurance policy of her own. Years later, I ended up participating in a focus group where I offered State Farm my insight on how they could explain the concept of renters insurance to others my age.

Even after those events, it wasn’t until I moved to Missouri when I finally decided it was time to look seriously at renters insurance. That’s when I discovered how inexpensive it really was. Given this realization, I want to take a in-depth look at renter’s insurance — including what it is, how it works, how to save money on your policy, and more — in hopes that you won’t put off purchasing this important product as long as I did.

Common Renters Insurance Questions

What is renters insurance?

Renters insurance is a policy that’s specifically intended to meet the needs of those who rent their homes as opposed to those who own property. While homeowners insurance policies may mostly be intended to cover damage to the houses and structures themselves, renters are rarely responsible for such things. Because of this, renters insurance policies instead focus on protecting what is in the home — e.g. your possessions.

What does renters insurance cover?

Similar to other types of insurance, there are many different types of renters insurance policies and customers may be able to select the specific types of coverage they’d like. However, a basic policy will still cover your belongings against a number of incidents. From fire damage to theft, you’ll be able to make a claim and be reimbursed if your possessions are affected.

  • Renters insurance policies will protect your stuff from these events and more:
  • Fires and lightning
  • Windstorms, tornados, and hail
  • Explosions
  • Riots
  • Damage by aircrafts
  • Damage by vehicles
  • Smoke damage
  • Vandalism
  • Theft
  • Volcanic eruptions
  • Falling objects
  • Weight of snow, ice, sleet
  • Frozen plumbing damage
  • Electrical short-circuit damage

What else do renters insurance policies cover?

Something that really surprised me when I first learned about renters insurance is that your items do not need to be damaged at or stolen from your home in order to be covered. Say you’re at a coffee shop and leave your laptop behind only to find it’s been stolen by the time you return. In this case, you could still file a renters insurance claim since the policy covers your possessions regardless of location

Another important aspect of renters insurance is that it may also cover expenses you incur from having to temporarily relocate. Say a fire in your apartment building spares the majority of your items but leaves your unit damaged enough to require a hotel stay until repairs can be made. Once again, this is where your renters insurance policy might be able to help out in cases where your landlord may not be required to cover such displacement costs.

Finally, many renters insurance policies also include liability protection. In short, this coverage is important in the event someone is injured on your property — whether by tripping over a hazard, dog bite, or other incidents you may be legally responsible for. Your coverage would help cover medical expenses as well as any legal fees you may incur up to your coverage limit.

What isn’t covered?

For all that renters insurance does cover, there are some things that it doesn’t — at least not in a basic policy. Two prime examples are floods and earthquakes. In both cases, you may be required to upgrade your policy or retain additional coverage to protect your items against these “acts of God.” You’ll also want to read your policy carefully to better understand what scenarios you’re protected against and which you’re not.

Is renters insurance required for renting?

Unlike in many states where car insurance is required in order for residents to register their vehicle and drive it, there are no laws mandating that you purchase a renters insurance policy in order to rent a property. That said, there are some landlords and rental companies that may make it a requirement of your lease terms. Moreover they may have coverage minimums you’ll need to meet in order to rent from them.

With that said, even if you aren’t required to have renters insurance, it’s often a good investment. That’s because, while it protects you from a number of financial disasters, policies can actually be quite affordable.

How much does renters insurance cost?

This is a tough question to answer because rates can vary greatly by location, insurer, and more. However, according to ValuePenguin, monthly premiums can start as low as $10 a month, with most policies costing less than $20 a month. Overall, the average renters insurance policy comes in at $187 a year, which works out to about $15.50 a month.

States with the highest average policy prices include Mississippi, Louisiana, Alabama, Oklahoma, and Texas where storms and flooding are of higher concern. In Mississippi, the average renters insurance policy costs $244 a year or just over $20 a month. Meanwhile states like North Dakota, South Dakota, Wisconsin, North Carolina, and Montana maintain lower than average policy pricing as concerns over earthquakes and hurricanes are minimal. The average renters insurance policy in North Dakota is just $115 a year — about $9.58 a month.

How are premiums priced?

An important note when talking about average policy prices is that they will vary depending on the amount of coverage you choose. For example, just like with other types of insurance, you elect to pay a higher premium (the amount you pay each month for coverage) in order to have a lower deductible (the amount you’ll pay out of pocket before your insurance kicks in when making a claim). As mentioned, you may wish to add protections to your policy to ensure you’re covered against floods and earthquakes, which can also raise your premium price.

Given the affordability of most renters insurance policies, it’s often worth looking into lower deductible options when possible. Additionally, in the section below we’ll explore a few ways you can save money on your renters insurance policy and get even more for less.

What’s the difference between replacement value (RV) and actual cash value (ACV) policies?

Speaking of factors that can affect your policies premium, you may be asked to choose between reimbursement options: replacement value (RV) or actual cash value (ACV). Essentially what this means is, would you rather be reimbursed for what it would cost you to buy brand new versions of your damaged items or receive the amount it would cost to purchase items in comparable condition to what they were before the qualifying incident? With an RV policy, you’ll be reimbursed for what the item goes for new while an ACV policy will factor in depreciation, wear and tear, ect. and reimburse you for just that amount.

Just as increasing your deductible can lower your premium, so can choosing an ACV policy plan over an RV one. Of course, if you don’t mind spending a little more in order to have your items truly covered, a replacement value renters insurance policy is probably the way to go.

With all that said, one slight misconception about replacement value policies is that your payout will be equal to how much you paid for the item in question. That’s not exactly true as you’ll likely only be paid the value of replacing that particular item — not a newer model — and prices can change over time. A great example of this is, say you paid $1,000 for a new iPhone X last year. If you file a claim for your phone and it now retails for $900, your payout would only by $900 (minus your deductible). Obviously this is probably still better than the actual cash value you’d receive but it’s worth noting nonetheless.

Are roommates, spouses, and significant others covered under my renters insurance policy?

Although policies will typically cover the possessions in your home or apartment, that doesn’t necessarily mean that stuff belonging to your roommate is automatically covered. In fact, the majority of policies won’t include coverage for roommates — at least not by default. Therefore you’ll probably want to advise your roomie to get their own policy just in case.

Of course, things may be a bit different if your roommate is your spouse. While you’ll still want to double-check, typically renters insurance companies will allow you to add your spouse to your policy for no extra charge. Meanwhile, when it comes to “significant others,” things are a bit vaguer. For example, while Lemonade allows spouses to be covered for free, there’s an additional charge for significant others (and regular roommates just need to purchase their own policies). So, once again, it’s best to consult your potential insurer to make sure you understand not only what your policy includes but also who it includes.

Saving Money on Renters Insurance

Bundle renters with auto insurance

One of the easiest ways to obtain renters insurance and score yourself a discount in the process is to bundle your policy with your auto insurance. Many top insurers offer both products while others may partner with another company to offer bundled services. For example, while my auto-insurance is through Geico, my renters insurance policy is actually with Assurant. However, thanks to Geico’s arrangement with Assurant, I still receive a small break on my auto insurance for having a renters policy.

Compare quotes

While bundling with your current auto insurance is an obvious first choice, it may not always be the cheapest option out there. That’s why you’ll still want to shop around for a few quotes and see if you may be able to save more money elsewhere.

When shopping around for quotes, make sure it’s an apples to apples comparison. This includes entering matching deductibles, understand what features are included and which you’ll want to add, and more. Additionally, while it is annoying to receive e-mails or even snail mail from multiple companies you’ve requested quotes from, it is important to enter accurate information (since prices can vary by location) to ensure that you’re getting an accurate quote.

Look for discounts

Beyond bundling, there may be other discounts you can qualify for that will save you money on your policy. In some cases the insurer may have a relationship with certain clubs you’re a member of or businesses you work for. If there’s no luck on that front, others may offer you a slight discount just for signing up for their auto-pay feature.

Another way in which renters insurance is similar to auto insurance is that you may qualify for discounts based on what types of security features your home is equipped with. As time goes on, you may also be able to trim your premium a bit since some insurers give discounts to customers who haven’t made claims on their policies. Just keep in mind that every company is different so you’ll want to inquire about discounts while you’re doing your comparison shopping.

Adjust your deductible

This one comes with an asterisk as it can save you money in the short term but potentially cost you in the long run. As I mentioned earlier, most insurers will allow you to select from a number of deductible options. By raising your deductible, you’ll likely lower your monthly premium.

Say, for example, that your $1,000 computer is stolen and you put in a renter’s insurance claim. If your deductible is $200, your policy will provide you $800 to replace it. However, if you’re deductible is $1,000, you’ll end up buying your new computer completely out of pocket.

Keep this in mind as your looking to lower your premium and be sure to compare your options. In some cases, it may only be a couple of dollars more a month to have a much lower deductible, so choose wisely!

Know what you actually own

Finally another way you can save money on renters insurance is to have a realistic total of how much coverage you need. One of the ways policies are priced is by determining the value of what’s being covered. Because of this, if you presume you have about $20,000 in possessions when you actually only have $10,000, you could be overspending.

What Else You Should Know About Renters Insurance

Documenting ownership of your possessions

Speaking of knowing what you own, something you’ll want to do before applying for a renters insurance policy is to take inventory of what you own. Cataloging your belongings will not only be helpful when purchasing your policy but will also be extremely helpful should you need to make a claim. While you can always use a regular spreadsheet to keep track of everything, there are also smartphone apps like Encircle that can help make the process a bit easier. Considering how easy it is to take pictures and video these days, it’s probably a good idea to have those on hand as well.

Several companies offer renters insurance policies

As I mentioned, a great place to start when looking to add a renters insurance policy is your auto insurer. Of course there are are plenty of other options when it comes to obtaining a policy as well. Some popular providers include:

Company Find Rates
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote
Get a Quote

You can also try out sites like Policygenius that will help you compare policies.

About Lemonade

One of the more interesting renters insurance companies around these days is Lemonade. Technically they operate under a peer to peer insurance model where premiums paid by members help fund claims from others (minus a flat fee that Lemonade takes to cover their operating costs). On top of that, the company donates any money left over in the fund to charity at the end of each year. For 2018, this amounted to $162,135.

The downside is that Lemonade is not yet available in all states. In fact, my resident state of Missouri is among the places they have yet to expand to. Still, having tried out their application process for myself and taken a look at their rates, I’m looking forward to their arrival (in the meantime, I’ll keep bundling my Assurant policy with Geico).

Given the numerous benefits that renters insurance policies can provide, it’s truly surprising that more individuals don’t carry coverage. The bottom line is that, for likely less than $20 a month, you can help protect your possessions against damage and theft, allowing you to replace them with little out-of-pocket costs. Additionally, with liability coverage and displacement reimbursement, having renters insurance is not only responsible but smart. Therefore I’d recommend that all renters look into obtaining their own policies as soon as possible.

Also published on Medium.


Kyle Burbank

Kyle is a freelance writer and author whose first book, "The E-Ticket Life" is now available on Amazon. In addition to his weekly "Money at 30" column on Dyer News, he is also the editorial director and a writer for the Disney fan site and has recently starting publsihing his own personal finance blog at

Other Articles by Kyle Burbank

Money at 30: My Initial Apple Card Review

Earlier this year, Apple announced what many had suspected: it was releasing its own credit card. While Goldman Sachs would be the ones actually issuing the product, the card would combine the user-friendly tech and stylish aesthetic that the company's cult has grown accustomed to. Now the Apple Card is...

Money at 30: The Spiteful Spending Paradox

No one likes to be scorned. Thus, when we feel we're being wronged, it's natural to not only want to stand up for ourselves but also stump for what we feel is right. Incidentally the same things can happen in finance, leading to what I've dedided to dub "spiteful spending."...

Bumped Review — Earn Stocks When You Shop 4

With a stellar line-up of brands on board and an easy-to-use platform, Bumped has quickly become one of my favorite financial apps to use. With Bumped still in its public beta phase, I'm very much looking forward to seeing what happens with the app from here. If all goes according...


Renter’s or housing insurance is one of the most important insurance policies that we should have. Few bucks per month is surely worth when something unfortunate happens.

It’s interesting to know that renters insurance will protect your belongings against fires and lightning, tornados, explosions or riots. A friend of my brother recommended him renters insurance, and we are looking for information. It could be a good idea since my brother is renting an apartment, to get renters insurance in case anything happens to his belongings.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *