What Banks Think About FinTech (and Vice Versa)

You’ve probably heard it said that in the case of many large predators you might encounter in the wild, it’s important to remember that they’re more afraid of you than you are of them. When it comes to the traditional banks’ perception of FinTech startups, that seems to be proving true. While few expect them to become entirely obsolete, a new study found that bankers are more bearish on the future of big banks than their FinTech counterparts are.

The Financial Brand recently reported on a new survey conducted by the Economic Intelligence Unit (EIU) which interviewed 100 senior bankers and 100 FinTech executives to get their thought on how financial technology companies might change the landscape. Among bankers the most popular response (with 33%) was that both banks and FinTech companies would dominate in different sectors. Nearly another quarter predicted banks and FinTechs would have about an equal share.

Only 20% stated that banks would continue to dominate. In the minority 10% felt that FinTech’s threat had been overhyped. On the other side of that coin, 5% feared that banks would become minor players in the future.

What’s more interesting are the answers the FinTech executives provided to the same questions. Their top response was that banks would continue to be dominant. In fact nearly half (46%) said as much. Coming in second was the idea that banks and FinTech would each dominate certain sectors.

Oddly even some FinTech executives felt that the impact of the space had been overstated — even more than the bankers. Meanwhile 5% felt that banks would be the minority, which was equal to the opposing side. Finally 10% thought banks would have an equal share with FinTech firms.

As part of the survey EIU also asked banks and FinTech companies what they thought the strengths of their businesses were. For banks the top responses were their reputation for stability followed closely by their customer loyalty and existing customer base. FinTech respondents said their companies were able to focus on a limited set of products, lacked any legacy systems that hindered the big banks, and had agility and speed when getting to market.

Similarly both sides were questioned about their weaknesses. As you might expect many of the banks’ weaknesses were FinTech’s strengths and vice versa. For example, FinTech execs said they needed to build their customer base — something that the big banks already have. However, the FinTech companies had the ability to innovate and bring new ideas to market while that remains a sore spot for many banks.

This EIU study highlights why many banks and financial technology companies are now looking to work together — something Renaud Laplanche, CEO of marketplace lender Lending Club, has spoken on in the past. That being said, the question remains how much FinTech companies can integrate into big banks without, in turn, inheriting some of their problems. Still it seems all but inevitable that we’ll see more partnerships between rivals forming in the coming years.


Jonathan Dyer

I'm a small town guy living in Los Angeles looking to make solid financial decisions. I write for a number of finance websites, including HuffingtonPost and Business2Community. I founded DyerNews.com in 2015 to focus on personal finance and the emerging FinTech markets.

Other Articles by Jonathan Dyer

Marqeta Expands Credit Program with New APIs and More

A FinTech that specializes in creating credit card experiences is rolling out some new features. This week, Marqeta announced what it calls a "significant expansion" of its credit platform. This includes more than 40 new credit APIs that will further help clients craft and launch their own credit card products. Additionally, the company notes an updated intuitive dashboard. Using this platform, businesses can create unique card options that can not...

PayPal Launches Small Business Credit Card with Flat 2% Cashback

The popular platform PayPal is rolling out a new product built specifically for small businesses. Today, the FinTech announced the launch of The PayPal Business Cashback Mastercard. The new card will be issued by WebBank and marks the first time PayPal has offered a business credit card. With the PayPal Business Cashback card, business owners will be able to earn 2% cashback on all purchases. This earning rate is not...

Wells Fargo Unveils New Autograph Rewards Visa Card

A new rewards credit card is on the way from Wells Fargo. Today, the bank introduced its Autograph card, which expands the company's refreshed card portfolio. In terms of rewards, the Wells Fargo Autograph Card will earn 3 points per dollar spent in a number of categories. These include restaurants, travel and transit, gas stations, select streaming services, and phone plans. All other purchases will earn 1x points. Beyond the...